Find the best seafood on Block Island! We’ve got the best seafood restaurants in New Shoreham/Block Island for you!
The BeacheadThis casual spot serving a surf ‘n’ turf menu has a welcoming country interior & a porch with waterfront views. Although they are known for fresh seafood, they have something for everyone. Dine al fresco on their garden patio or porch overlooking the ocean. Enjoy traditional New England food with a fun, updated twist!
The Oar, a casual American restaurant with the added bonus of a fabulous sushi menu serves lunch and dinner daily overlooking the Great Salt Pond. The Oar, located at the Boat Basin in New Harbor on the beautiful Great Salt Pond, has something for everyone, including the area’s best clam chowder, New England lobster rolls, burgers, and a full sushi bar. Kick back on the back deck, featuring an unrivaled view of Great Salt Pond, as you enjoy a leisurely lunch or a sip of their famous Block Island Mudslide.
Come for the food and stay for the view! Dead Eye Dick’s at Payne’s Dock in New Harbor offers the freshest seafood, including Dead Eye’s signature swordfish and lobster dishes. Open from May through September, diners can enjoy homemade soups, an extensive raw bar, creative cocktails, wine, and microbrews in our casual dining room or outside on the deck overlooking New Harbor. The perfect place to bring a date or host a family dinner!
Ballard’s is a staple when visiting Block Island! Whether it’s just to grab a beer to drink on the beach or for a whole meal, they’ve got it all! Their extensive menu means there’s truly something for everyone. Between the live music, outdoor bars, and beach cabanas and loungers, Ballard’s really is a party!
Looking for quiet spot to enjoy a cocktail or dinner with your date or best friend? Hotel Manisses is the place to go. Hot tip: take your drinks or food out to their sunken garden oasis behind the hotel…you can thank us later!
Located in the center of downtown in Old Harbor across from the ferry landing and New England’s best beaches, the National is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. This Block Island landmark offers breath-taking ocean views from the iconic front porch and restaurant, the Tap and Grille—a favorite gathering spot for locals and visitors.